Home › Selling an inherited house
Selling an inherited house on Long Island
Inheriting a house usually comes at a hard time, and it brings a long list of decisions: who has the authority to sell, what to do with everything inside, whether to fix anything, and what the house is worth. Homeside Realty has helped Long Island families sell inherited and estate homes since 1991. Here is how the process usually works.
1. Confirm who can sell the house
Before a house can be listed, someone needs the legal authority to sign for it. How that works depends on how the property was owned:
- The house is in the estate. The executor named in the will, or an administrator if there is no will, gets authority from the Surrogate's Court in the county where the owner lived. In Suffolk that is the Suffolk County Surrogate's Court in Riverhead; in Nassau, the Nassau County Surrogate's Court in Mineola. See our guide to probate home sales.
- The house was held in a trust. The trustee can usually sell under the terms of the trust without going through probate.
- The house passed directly to a surviving owner (for example, a spouse who owned it jointly). The surviving owner can usually sell in their own name.
Your estate attorney will confirm which of these applies. We work alongside attorneys every week and can list the home as soon as the paperwork allows.
2. Secure and maintain the property
An empty house needs attention. Keep the homeowner's insurance in force and tell the insurer the house is vacant, keep the heat on in winter to protect the pipes, forward the mail, and have someone check on it regularly. These steps protect the value of the house while the estate is settled.
3. Decide what to do with the contents
Families usually take what they want to keep first, then use an estate sale company, donations, and a cleanout service for the rest. A clean, empty (or lightly staged) house shows better and sells faster. We can recommend Long Island estate sale and cleanout companies we trust.
4. Repair, update, or sell as-is?
Many inherited homes have not been updated in years. You do not have to renovate before selling. The right answer depends on the house and the market:
- Sell as-is when repairs are major, the heirs want a quick and simple sale, or the house will appeal to buyers who plan to renovate.
- Do light work (cleaning, paint, landscaping, small repairs) when a modest spend will clearly raise the price more than it costs.
We will walk the house with you and give you a straight answer on what is worth doing and what is not. See also selling a house as-is on Long Island.
5. Price it from real local sales
Estate homes that are priced right sell quickly. Pricing is based on recent closed sales of similar homes nearby, adjusted for condition. Our Long Island home prices by town page shows current price per square foot and sales activity from OneKey MLS. For a specific number on your house, request a free home value estimate.
Your attorney or accountant may also need a formal date-of-death appraisal for tax purposes. That is done by a licensed appraiser, and we can refer one.
6. Taxes and dividing the proceeds
Inherited property often receives a "stepped-up" tax basis, generally its value at the date of death, which can reduce or eliminate capital gains tax when the house is sold. Estate tax rules, the step-up, and how proceeds are divided among heirs all depend on the details, so talk with your accountant and estate attorney before you sign a contract.
When the heirs disagree
It is common for siblings or relatives to have different ideas about timing, price, or whether one heir should buy out the others. A clear, data-based valuation and regular updates from one point of contact go a long way. We keep every heir informed so decisions are made on the same facts.
Why families call Homeside Realty
- Licensed Real Estate Broker Frank J. Profeta has sold Long Island real estate since 1991.
- Deep experience with estate, inherited, bank-owned (REO), and short-sale properties, including homes that need work.
- Owner-led: you work directly with the broker, not a call center.
- Serving Suffolk and Nassau Counties.
This page is general information, not legal or tax advice. Every estate is different; please consult your estate attorney and accountant.
Talk to Frank J. Profeta
Licensed Real Estate Broker, serving Suffolk and Nassau Counties since 1991. Straight answers, no pressure.
Get my free home valueCall (631) 289-5151